Tomatoes With Basil and Anchovies Recipe (2024)

Ratings

5

out of 5

141

user ratings

Your rating

or to rate this recipe.

Have you cooked this?

or to mark this recipe as cooked.

Private Notes

Leave a Private Note on this recipe and see it here.

Cooking Notes

leah

I think I would blend the anchovies with the vinegar and oil instead of adding them whole to the salad. The vinegar will tame the amines (cause of the fishy taste) and will entice even those who find anchovies revolting to partake of this salad.

Candice

I whisk the garlic, shallots, salt, and pepper into the oil first, and then add the vinegar. It seems to emulsify better that way.

Laura Zinn Fromm

I chopped the anchovies up very fine so that no one would know they were in there! We had a big group over for brunch and they loved this salad---but might have balked if they had seen that anchovies were in there before digging in.

nostalchik2

I would use only 6 anchovies. - Great idea to blend with the vinegar and oil.

ranu

I didn't have shallots on hand but garlic, olive oil and vinegar did the trick just fine. So flavorful and delicious. Letting the tomatoes sit in the vinaigrette for at least 10 mins is key.

Melinda

I blended the dressing and liked the creamy texture.
I had Thai basil on hand and used it instead of standard basil and because of the firmer texture did a chiffonade rather than whole leaves.

The dish was enjoyed by all my guests - even the non-anchovy eaters.
A definite winner.

Andrea

Anchovies makes everything better. I’m not hiding mine. Yum!!!

Steven Andrea

This was great. Followed some suggestions and put some anchovy in the dressing and some on top. We love anchovies on bread so we made little bites and loved it. Also had on hand some lobster meat, cooked it up with garlic and evoo and mixed it in as well (at room temp). A delightful “slightly fishy” tomato salad which became dinner. The dressing is simple, and lovely.

Renorose

Simple and perfect. I used sweet and mild white anchovies and tossed in a few pitted Kalamata olives. Brilliant!

Grant Rockett

Didn't do much for me, and was rather a bit of trouble to make. I prefer a plain old tomato and basil salad with a vinaigrette dressing.

Dbrsk more update

Can use a little fish sauce in lieu of anchoviesIf using anchovies add salt at end since they are salty

Laura Zinn Fromm

I chopped the anchovies up very fine so that no one would know they were in there! We had a big group over for brunch and they loved this salad---but might have balked if they had seen that anchovies were in there before digging in.

AJ

Terrific way to showcase the bounty of summer, heirloom tomatoes. Fast, delicious, healthy -- what's not to love?

ranu

I didn't have shallots on hand but garlic, olive oil and vinegar did the trick just fine. So flavorful and delicious. Letting the tomatoes sit in the vinaigrette for at least 10 mins is key.

Dan

This is even better the next day

Peggy

Great taste summer tastes with an ear of Jersey corn....made half the recipe as I'm cooking for myself these days. I chopped the anchovies and soaked in dressing as leah suggested, added avocado!

PatB

This very good! Hardly tasted the anchovies. Great way to use the summer's sweet tomatoes.

Melinda

I blended the dressing and liked the creamy texture.
I had Thai basil on hand and used it instead of standard basil and because of the firmer texture did a chiffonade rather than whole leaves.

The dish was enjoyed by all my guests - even the non-anchovy eaters.
A definite winner.

Candice

I whisk the garlic, shallots, salt, and pepper into the oil first, and then add the vinegar. It seems to emulsify better that way.

401h20

Excellent recipe - nothing to be added or deleted. Perfect for summer eclectic fun.

leah

I think I would blend the anchovies with the vinegar and oil instead of adding them whole to the salad. The vinegar will tame the amines (cause of the fishy taste) and will entice even those who find anchovies revolting to partake of this salad.

nostalchik2

I would use only 6 anchovies. - Great idea to blend with the vinegar and oil.

Private notes are only visible to you.

Tomatoes With Basil and Anchovies Recipe (2024)

FAQs

Why put anchovies in tomato sauce? ›

Anchovies can add depth of flavor to tomato-based sauces, such as marinara or arrabbiata, and they are also commonly used in pasta dishes that feature seafood, such as spaghetti alle vongole. They can also be used in other types of pasta sauces, such as pesto, to add a rich umami flavor.

How to cook with anchovies? ›

Ideas for Using Anchovies
  1. Add them to your tomato sauce—cook anchovies with some garlic and olive oil before adding your tomatoes for a tasty pasta sauce.
  2. Use it in rubs for meat—mash or blend up garlic, an anchovy, rosemary, and lemon zest for an amazing rub for lamb chops or steak.
Aug 8, 2021

Why do people cook with anchovies? ›

Recipes often call for cooking anchovies until they "melt," i.e. disappear into the fat: They imbue the finished product with a jolt of umami—a why's-this-so-good-deliciousness—that doesn't taste at all "like the sea."

What seasoning goes with tomatoes? ›

While basil, cilantro, and oregano are all popular herbs to pair with Tomatoes, there are many more options to choose from! If you want to experiment with more herbs, here are a few extra options that taste great with Tomatoes: Parsley. Dill.

Why do anchovies have a bad reputation? ›

The main reason for the fish's bad reputation might be the way it's processed and packaged. For the most part, anchovy filets are cured, packed into barrels or other containers of salt for several months.

Do Italians put anchovies in their sauce? ›

Italians are more likely to mince up an anchovy or two and use it in their sauce, rather than fish sauce. You can find fish sauce in Italy, I'm sure, and there might be more than a few people adding a dash or two to their pasta sauces. It's not a bad idea, but the anchovy is more traditional.

What pairs well with anchovies? ›

Remember, anchovies play well with other salty, acidic, and briny ingredients, like olives, tomatoes, and capers. Next time you're making a pasta dish, try sliding in just a few anchovies — the results will not disappoint.

Do canned anchovies need to be cooked? ›

Yup, that's right, you can snack on those fishes straight out of the jar, especially when you've grabbed the good stuff—high-quality anchovies are tender and meaty, with a silky texture and clean brininess.

Are you supposed to cook canned anchovies? ›

While these tiny fish are delicious fresh from the water, most of us are more familiar with the canned variety. Because of their small size, the bones can be (and are) eaten. And when cooked, the canned anchovies, bones and all, will almost completely dissolve or "melt," leaving only the flavor.

Are anchovies good or bad for you? ›

They are best known as a source of omega-3 fatty acids, which promote brain and heart health. Anchovies also have selenium, which, if eaten regularly, may reduce the risk of some types of cancer. Anchovies are rich in omega-3 fatty acids, which offer powerful benefits for your heart.

Can I eat anchovies straight from the tin? ›

Flavorful oil-packed anchovy fillets, commonly found at the supermarket, can be plucked right out of the tin or jar they come in.

How do Italians eat anchovies? ›

They are easy to cook, whether batter dip and fried, served with a salsa of capers and parsley, or quick “cooked” in vinegar and dressed with olive oil and parsley. They are also widely preserved, salted and canned to use in a variety of ways, on pizza, on bread, and in pasta sauces.

What makes tomato taste better? ›

Yes, there are other ways to make your tomatoes taste even better and increase the acidity. There is lemon, vinegar, or my personal favorite, balsamic. Just imagine a tomato bruschetta with a balsamic vinaigrette drizzled on top.

What herb is best for tomatoes? ›

Basil is the number one herb for tomatoes, but other herbs compliment tomatoes as well: bay, chives, dill, marjoram, oregano, parsley, rosemary, savory, tarragon and thyme. Use them by themselves or in combination with tomatoes. Planting basil next to you tomatoes helps both grow better.

What gives tomatoes good flavor? ›

And flavor, said Jay Scott, an emeritus tomato breeder at the University of Florida, basically comes down to just three things — sugar, acids, and aromatic volatiles. Some people like much sweeter tomatoes while others like less sweet tomatoes — no one tomato variety will ever be a “perfect” tomato to everyone.

Why put anchovies in spaghetti sauce? ›

Despite their reputation, anchovies are not overpowering, at least once cooked. Used with garlic as the start of a fast pasta sauce, they dissolve almost instantly and add a mysteriously meaty complexity that makes the sauce seem as if it had simmered for hours.

Why do you put anchovies in pasta? ›

In Italian cooking, anchovies are extremely common. They don't add so much of a "fishy" taste as much as a salty, umami punch of flavor. For that, I always keep anchovy paste, oil or filets on hand to give pasta dishes like this a boost of flavor.

Why are anchovies used in fish sauce? ›

Anchovies are small fish, and have been used as a base in many sauces since Roman times. They are added due to their strong flavor.

Why put anchovies in BBQ sauce? ›

You might be surprised to find out that some of the most popular brands of BBQ sauce contain anchovies—a type of small fish that's included to retain saltiness and produce an umami flavor. Likewise, a common ingredient in some BBQ sauces is Worcestershire sauce, which is made using fermented anchovies as well.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Melvina Ondricka

Last Updated:

Views: 6332

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (48 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Melvina Ondricka

Birthday: 2000-12-23

Address: Suite 382 139 Shaniqua Locks, Paulaborough, UT 90498

Phone: +636383657021

Job: Dynamic Government Specialist

Hobby: Kite flying, Watching movies, Knitting, Model building, Reading, Wood carving, Paintball

Introduction: My name is Melvina Ondricka, I am a helpful, fancy, friendly, innocent, outstanding, courageous, thoughtful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.